With Oriel Gallery, Dublin, July 1979;
Whence purchased by William and Joan Roth, USA;
Adam's, 29 September 2004, lot 139 as ‘Reclining Male Nude’;
It may well be that the origins of the present work date from this period, and the figure element, executed in pencil, could indeed have been one of a number of studies for that work, as Orpen attempted to resolve the pose for the corpse. Konody’s comments hold true for many of the artists following in the neo-classical and historic traditions. Orpen, in his rapacious thirst for art history and tradition would not only be able to draw on the religious paintings of Ribera and trace them through to works such as Thèodule Ribot’s Le Samaritain (1870) (Musèe d’Orsay, Paris), but also would combine them with other traditions such as the Irish Romantics, characterised by such works as James Barry’s Death of Adonis (c.1775) (National Gallery of Ireland), or Francis Danby’s The Precipice aka Death of an Alpine Hunter (c.1827) (City of Bristol Museum and Art Gallery), or Harry Jones Thaddeus’s The Wounded Poacher (1880-1881) (National Gallery of Ireland) or with the Scottish Historical tradition, such as David Scott’s Philoctetes left in the Isle of Lemnos by the Greeks, in their Passage towards Troy (1840) (National Galleries of Scotland) (See footnote no. 2)
As the artist’s style developed and matured, and the vista of his genre works opened out from those interiors, so characteristic of the turn-of-the century New English Art Club, to the broader canvases and challeges of the open air, the dominance given to line, increasingly gave way to colour and form, a development no doubt feulled by the awe-inspiring, ever-changing skies over Dublin Bay, which Orpen regularly painted as he holidayed in Howth between 1909 and 1914 (see footnote no. 3), and later by the strange and eerie beauty of the sun-baked battlefields of the Western Front (see footnote no. 4), and onimous billowing clouds over Paris (see footnote no. 5).
Orpen exulted the incongruity of the strong yet suble, sometime contrasting, sometime harmonious, colours, that nature created in its landscapes, seascapes and cloudscapes, and in consequence his pallette developed to accommodate them. Throughout the 1920s Orpen subjugated his own freedom to explore through genre painting to concentrate on his portrait business. However, in the last few months of his life, he branched out from commissioned portraiture to produce a series of works, often unfinished, seemingly very different from anything else he produced before. Orpen’s health was failing rapidly at that time, and he must have been aware that his time was short, but he was determined to work to the very end. He still had things to say, things he had put off for a decade, things emanating from a new conciousness arising from his changing medical condition. Consequently the pictures, forged by a new urgency, do not have the finesse of previous works, but they do contain passion, vision, commitment and unity of expression. Evidently they must have meant a great deal to the artist for he submitted three of the more major pictures, Palm Sunday A.D.33 (1931) (Private Collection), Eve in the Garden of Eden (1931) (Royal Academy, London) and Pavlova on a Beach (1931) (Mildura Arts Centre, Australia), to public scrutiny at the Royal Academy Summer Exhibition in 1931.
Consisting of two intertwining strands these last works are set in an indeterminate location comprising earth, sea and sky, that may be an idealised reference to Howth and Dublin Bay, the character of which can change from idyllic sunshine to stormy turmoil in the blink of an eye. It is this duality that is reflected, with the female form representing serenity and the male form turmoil. When we gaze upon these works we are experiencing Orpen’s visualisation of the Agony and the Ecstasy, yet still the romantic is corralled by realism, as he did three decades before with The Rebel. Only now with the balance tipped in favour of the romantic. Realism was achieved by the preservation of line, and as his faculties deteriorated, the ingenious artist resorted to various subterfuges to compensate. Among these would be the use of photographs, tracing, or using old academic pencil studies of the nude and adding a background based upon colour and form, which did not require the same precision in its handling. The current work falls into this category, the figure itself could possibly be a trace of , or an earlier study. (See footnote no 6)
The quality of the works suggest Orpen was trying to aspire to some supernatural vision, as if he was looking through his own approaching death to the after-life. All the pictures possess a mystical or spiritual quality, and a number of them have a religious theme or title. Religion had taken on a greater significance in these last years. He had become friendly with a Roman Catholic priest and had installed his own little Chapel in his revamped studio completed in 1929. One could imagine, the recumbent figure representing Orpen himself, a tortured soul, as he comtemplates the haunting images of Ribera’s Christ and martyrs which had been etched in his memory all those years before. As his dexterity wanes, colour becomes increasing more important to express his feelings, and these pictures of the male nude are far darker in colour and tone than the more serene ones involving the female form. The stillness of those pictures is replaced with a disturbing sky, full of movement and menace, where even the seagulls are agitated. There is no peace here. This is more akin to purgatory than to heaven, and the man’s implied suffering may well be a manifestation of Orpen’s guilt and loathing at certain aspects of his life as he prepares to meet his Maker. Is he in purgatory, naked before God, racked by pain both mental and physical, atoning for his sins in a neverland? Taking the current work as an example, just as with Van Gogh, or Dadd, whatever governed Orpen’s thoughts in the last months, he still was able to produce powerful and challenging works, focuses for meditation, that have the ability to cause a stir, divide opinion, court controversy, shock and bewilder. As such this oft dismissed small but significant part of his ouvre should not be rejected or ignored. Instead it must be embraced, for it represents the closing bracket around the artistic life of a great painter.
1. For a more detailed assessment of these works, especially The Rebel, refer to P.G. Konody’s comments in P.G. Konody and Sidney Dark, Sir William Orpen, Artist and Man, Seeley Service, London, 1932, p.158.
2 This pose adopted for the current work, or variants, can be seen in many works of neo classical, historic and romantic painters in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. Further examples include William Blake’s The Spiritual Form of Nelson Guiding Leviathan, c.1805-9 (Tate Gallery, London) and David Scott’s, Russians Burying their Dead, 1831-2 (Hunterian Art Gallery, University of Glasgow). Perhaps of greatest interest, however, is the latters’ 1840 rendition of Philoctetes left in the Isle of Lemnos by the Greeks, in their Passage towards Troy, which seems to have been inspired by William Wordsworth’s 1827 Sonnet, When Philoctetes in the Lemnian Isle, rather than directly from the Greek legend:
WHEN Philoctetes in the Lemnian isle
Like a form sculptured on a monument
Lay couched; on him or his dread bow unbent
Some wild bird oft might settle and beguile
The rigid features of a transient smile,
Disperse the tear, or to the sigh give vent,
Slackening the pains of ruthless banishment
From his loved home, and from heroic toil.
And trust that spiritual Creatures round us move,
Griefs to allay which Reason cannot heal;
Yea, veriest reptiles have sufficed to prove
To fettered wretchedness, that no Bastile
Is deep enough to exclude the light of love,
Though man for brother man has ceased to feel.
Although viewed from a different angle, Philocetetes’ pose closely resembles the pose of the nude in the subject work. This along with the nature and placement of the accoutrements, the bow and quiver of arrows for Scott and the hat and firearn for Orpen, coupled with the similarity in the beards suggest that this may have been one of Orpen’s references when undertaking The Rebel. Scott’s painting had been acquired by the National Gallery of Scoland in 1890. It is also not inconceivable that Orpen knew that Scott’s source was Wordsworth, and that he was also conversant with the sonnet. However, whereas in The Rebel, he was using elements of Scott’s picture for a composition in relation to a different subject, with regard to the present work, the added elements surrounding the central figure, together with colour and tone of the torso suggest a direct connection with the sonnet on the one hand and a link to Scott’s work on the other. It may well be that the sentiments expressed by Wordsworth found a resonance with Orpen in his twilight days.
3 Examples include: A Breezy Day, Howth (1912) (Hugh Lane Gallery of Modern Art, Dublin) Bringing In the Boat (c.1912) (Private Collection), and Dublin Bay From Howth Head (c.1912) (Private Collection). For further discussion see Orpen Research Project, Christie’s Irish Sale, 19 May 2000 Catalogue, Lot.184. pp.162-3, Christie’s, London, 2000.
4 Examples include: The Main Street, Combles (1917) (Imperial War Museum, London) and Harvest, 1918 (Imperial War Museum, London)
5 Clouds Over Montmartre (c.1919) (Private Collection). For further discussion see Orpen Research Project, Sotheby’s Irish Sale, 13 May 2004 Catalogue, , Lot.34. p.55., Sotheby’s, London, 2004.
6 Other works to be considered: Based on the male nude - Male Nude Study (Private Collection); On the Edge of the Cliff (Private Collection); and Nude, Male Lying on a Rock [No.1] (Private Collection), and based on the Female form - Mother and Child on a Beach (Royal Academy, London); Nude Female Model Reading on a Seashore (Royal Academy, London) ; and Nude, Female, Back - Looking to Sea (Private Collection).
- Auction Details
(a) Each lot is put up subject to any reserve price imposed by the vendor
(b) Subject to sub-clause (a) of this clause, the highest bidder for each lot shall be the purchaser thereof
(c) If any dispute arises as to the highest bidder the auctioneer shall have absolute discretion to determine the dispute and may put up again and re-sell the lot in respect of which the dispute arises.
(a) The bidding and advances shall be regulated by and at the absolute discretion of the auctioneer and he shall have the right to refuse any bid or bids. NOTE: Where an agent bids, even on behalf of a disclosed client, the auctioneer nevertheless has the right at his discretion to refuse any such bid.
(b) The purchaser of each lot shall immediately on its sale, if required by the auctioneer, give him the name and address of the purchaser and pay to the auctioneer at his discretion the whole or part of the purchase money. If the purchaser of any lot fails to comply with any such requirement the auctioneer may put up again and re-sell the lot; if upon such re-sale a lower price is obtained than was obtained on the first sale the purchaser in default on the first sale shall make good the difference in price and expenses of re-sale which shall become a debt due from him.
(c) Where an agent purchases on behalf of an undisclosed client such agent shall be personally liable for payment of the purchase money to the auctioneer and for safe delivery of the lot to the said client.
(a) The auctioneer reserves the rights to bid on behalf of clients including vendors, but shall not be liable for errors or omissions in executing instructions to bid.
(b) The auctioneer reserves the rights, before or during a sale, to group together lots belonging to the same vendor, to split up and to withdraw any lot or lots at the auctioneer's absolute discretion and without giving any reason in any case.
(c) The auctioneer acts as agent only, and therefore shall not be liable for any default of the purchaser or vendor.
(a) Each lot shall be at the purchaser's risk from the fall of the hammer and shall be paid for in full before delivery and taken away at his expense within one day of the sale. The buyer will be responsible for all removal, storage and insurance charges in respect of any lot which has not been collected within one day of the date of sale. (b) If any purchaser fails to pay in full for any lot within 21 days of the date of sale such lot may at any time thereafter at the auctioneer's discretion be put up for sale by auction again or sold privately; if upon such re-sale a lower price is obtained than was obtained on the first sale the purchaser in default on the first sale shall make good the difference in price and the expenses of re-sale which shall become debt due from him. (c) Interest at 2 per cent per month and legal costs (if any) for recovery of monies due shall be payable by the purchaser on any overdue account.
(a) All lots are made available for inspection before each sale and each buyer, by making a bid, acknowledges that he has satisfied himself as to the physical condition, age and catalogue description of each lot (including but not restricted to whether the lot is damaged or has been repaired or restored).
(b) All lots are sold with all faults and imperfections and errors of description and the Auctioneer and its employees, servants or agents shall not be responsible for any error of description or for the condition or authenticity of any lot, save for Clause 5 (c) below. Written or verbal condition reports may be supplied by the Auctioneer on request but these are merely statements of opinion, and any error or omission in these reports may not be taken as grounds for a cancellation of sale or refund of any part of the purchase price or the cost of any repairs to the lot or lots reported on
(c) A purchaser shall be at liberty to reject any lot if he - (i) gives the auctioneer written notice of intention to question the genuineness of the lot within seven days from the date of sale; AND (ii) proves that the lot is a deliberate forgery and (iii) returns to the auctioneer within 20 days from the date of sale the lot in the same condition as it was at the time of sale; provided that the auctioneer may, at his discretion, on receiving a request in writing from the purchaser, extend for a reasonable period the time for return of the lot to enable it to be submitted to expertisation. NOTE: The onus of proving a lot to be a deliberate forgery is on the purchaser.
(d) Where a lot has been submitted to expertisation, all costs of such expertisation shall be paid by the person who retains the certificate of expertisation and item or items to which the certificate relates.
(e) Where the purchaser of a lot discharges the onus and acts in accordance with sub-clause (b) of this clause, the auctioneer shall rescind the sale and repay to the purchaser the purchase money paid by him in respect of the lot.
(f) No lot shall be rejected if, subsequent to the sale, it has been marked by an expert committee or treated by any other process unless the auctioneer's permission to subject the lot to such treatment has first been obtained in writing.
(g) Any lot listed as a "collection, range, portfolio etc." or stated to comprise or contain a collection or range of items which are not described shall be put up for sale not subject to rejection and shall be taken by the purchaser with all (if any) faults, lack of genuineness and errors of description and numbers of items in the lot, and the purchaser shall have no right to reject the lot; except that, notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this sub-clause, where before a sale a person intending to bid at the sale gives notice in writing to, and satisfies the auctioneer that any such lot contains any item or items undescribed in the sale catalogue and that person specifically describes that item or those items in that notice, then that item or those items shall, as between the auctioneer and that person, to be taken to form part of the description of the lot.
The respective rights and obligations of the parties shall be governed and interpreted by Irish law, and the buyer hereby submits to the exclusive jurisdiction of the Irish Courts.
a) The buyer shall pay the Auctioneer a commission at the rate of 20% up to and including €3 million, and 13.5% of that part of the hammer price over €3 million. The Buyer's Premium is added to the hammer price of all lots and is subject to VAT at the prevailing rate. There is no extra charge to on-line buyers on Whyte’s platform – bid.whytes.ie or on Invaluable.com.
(b) The Auctioneer or its employees, servants or agents may, on request organise packing and shipping of lots purchased or may order on the buyer's behalf third parties to pack or ship purchases. Under no circumstances does the Auctioneer accept any liability whatsoever for any loss or damage howsoever occasioned in the course of such service.
(c) The buyer authorises the Auctioneer to use any photographs or illustrations of any lot purchased for any or all purposes as the Auctioneer may require. The placing of a bid will be taken as full agreement to all the above conditions.
WHYTE AND SONS AUCTIONEERS LIMITED, 2018.
YOU CAN LEAVE BIDS OR BID LIVE ON THE INTERNET - all our sales are broadcast live with video and audio at NO EXTRA COST to buyers. Register using www.bid.whytes.ie or follow the link to LIVE BIDDING from our main websites www.whytes.ie or www.whytes.com . For a guide to bidding on-line click here
YOU CAN BID LIVE ON THE TELEPHONE: (on lots with a high estimate of €1,000+ only) we can arrange to telephone you on lots you are interested in and you can bid live over the phone. This service is offered subject to availability of lines and we accept no responsibility whatsoever for not being able to contact clients during the auction for any reason, be it technical difficulty or otherwise.
YOU CAN LEAVE YOUR BIDS FOR US TO PLACE – just use the bidding form provided. You can fill it in and leave it with our staff or email it in to our office – preferably at the very least an hour before the sale starts. Our staff will be happy to help you with this
YOU CAN E-MAIL BIDS to firstname.lastname@example.org You will need to include your full name and address and telephone number as well as photo id and proof of address - a driver's licence will cover both requirements.
A FEW TIPS FOR ABSENTEE BIDDERS:
Bid the maximum price you would pay for the lot; we will try and secure the lot for you at the lowest possible price. For instance if you bid €2,000 on a lot and the highest other bid we receive is €1,200 you get it for €1,250.
Most people tend to bid in round numbers, e.g. €500. It’s often a good idea to bid an odd number, e.g. €520, or €540 which will outbid an even number.
“Break ties” or “Plus 1” Bids: give us discretion to increase your bid by one step to beat a bid equal to yours.
Interested in several lots but only want to buy one or two? You can enter bids on any number of lots but limit the grand total spent. Lots are bid on in the numerical order they appear in the catalogue.
You can also use alternatives: just write “OR” between the lots e.g “Lot 30 €1,000 OR Lot 34 €2,000 OR Lot 38 €1,600”.
Check the results the day after the sale: these are published on our website www.whytes.ie at about 10am on the day after the sale. Successful bidders are also notified of results by mail.
FOR HELP AND ADVICE ON BIDDING PLEASE EMAIL email@example.com OR TELEPHONE 01 676 2888 (+3531 6762888)
Good luck with your bidding!